How to test RESTful API Clients
All my current projects involve a RESTful JSON API that is consumed by multiple clients. While it is pretty easy to write integration tests for the API itself it can be tricky to do so for the clients.
In one of my projects (duse-io) there are client libraries for several languages. We first wanted a common approach for testing all clients. Since the API is documented with apiary, we thougth we can just test against the generated mock API.
However we soon noticed, that the mock API did not fully statisfy our needs. The problem with apiarys mock API is that it can only be used for one case for every route. In other words you can only test one case of each route of the clients use of the API. No one can really call that tested.
Our next idea was to write a mocked API ourselves and test against those. But once we started writing the mock API we noticed something else, we were writing the server all over again.
The current solution is to use something similar to webmock in each language, which we believe is the best way to tackle the problem, since we can specify the APIs behaviour for each test.
Even though this approach works it creates a redundancy among all of our client libraries: we are constantly syncronizing tests between the libaries. One acronym: DRY. There should be a better way.
Edit: It turns out I am not the only one bothering this. I found pact, which can be used to specify how a client wants to use an API and it generates tests for the api as well as mocks for the client.